Local Florida Agents >
Columbia
> Top Real Estate Agent
JM
Johnathan Mathis
Top Recommended
Pointer Properties
Usually responds within 1 hour
Lake City
, Florida
Years of Experience
6
Transactions
90
Single Family Homes
97%+
5.0
(
10
 reviews)
Language
English
Spanish
Counties served
Suwannee
Columbia
Hamilton
Madison

About

Johnathan Mathis

As a Realtor with Pointer Properties, I bring a unique blend of passion and experience to the table. I've collaborated with numerous investors to successfully navigate complex deals, including residential and multi-family properties. Having lived in Live Oak and Hamilton County for many years, I possess in-depth knowledge of these areas and the surrounding communities. I'm adept at tackling challenging situations, consistently finding solutions where others may have given up. Benefitting from years of exposure to the real estate industry, I've developed a strong understanding of the market dynamics. Whether you're a seasoned investor or a first-time homebuyer, I'm committed to providing you with exceptional service. Let me leverage my expertise to help you achieve your real estate goals.

Jeff Tricoli’s Reviews and Ratings

Tell us about your experience with

Johnathan Mathis

Add review
Add a Review
Johnathan helped me buy a home

If I could give Johnathan 10 stars, I would. From start to finish, he was patient, knowledgeable, and on it. Buying a home can feel overwhelming, but he made the entire process smooth, organized, and stress-free. Every question I had, he answered quickly and clearly. I never felt out of the loop. He advocated for me, explained everything in detail, and made sure I felt confident in every decision. Not once did I feel pressured—just supported. That kind of professionalism is rare. If you want a realtor who communicates, moves with integrity, and truly cares about his clients, Johnathan is your guy. He didn’t just help me buy a house—he made sure I walked into my new home feeling secure and excited. Highly recommend. 100/10 experience.

Johnathan helped me buy a home

I can’t say enough great things about Johnathan. From our very first conversation, it was clear that he was not only knowledgeable about the market but genuinely cared about helping me find the right home. His professionalism, responsiveness, and attention to detail made the entire process smooth and stress-free. What really stood out was how communicative and proactive he was—always one step ahead, keeping me informed and answering every question along the way. Johnathan negotiated skillfully on my behalf and made sure I felt confident and supported through each stage. If you’re looking for someone who goes above and beyond, is honest and professional, I highly recommend Johnathan. Truly five-star service!

Tristan helped me sell my home

Tristan did a fantastic job with the sale of our home. He was consistently available for questions, kept us updated throughout the process, and helped maximize our sale price. He was a great mediator between us and all parties involved, worked through contract negotiations, accommodated our requests, and made the sale as smooth as possible.

Tristan helped me buy a home

Tristan is an outstanding realtor. He helped me find the perfect property in Live Oak, Florida. He responds quickly to texts and phone calls, is very knowledgeable about the areas he serves, has access to properties you don’t see on Zillow, and provides detailed listings with tax information. He is professional and a pleasure to work with. I highly recommend him in your search for a new home.

Johnathan helped me buy and sell multiple homes

Johnathan goes above and beyond for his clients. He has helped me with multiple purchases and sales and is always looking out for my best interests. He goes beyond what I’ve ever experienced with other realtors to ensure every purchase and sale goes smoothly. 10/10 would recommend.

Client FAQs

Are there any fees associated with this referral service?

No, there is no cost to use our referral service.

Am I obligated to work with an agent once I submit the request form?

Not at all. Submitting a request does not create any obligation to work with a referred agent. While we carefully vet the professionals on our platform and know you’ll be in good hands, you are always free to decide whether the relationship is the right fit for you.

What selection criteria is used for the platform’s agents?

Our agents are vetted extensively to meet our rigorous standards. For an in-depth overview of this criteria, please visit the ‘Standard’ section.

Is Southlight affiliated with a brokerage?

No, Southlight is an independent platform and is not owned or affiliated with any single brokerage, allowing us to connect clients with trusted, area-specific experts.

What does it cost to work with an agent?

In most cases, real estate agents are compensated through a commission based on a percentage of the final sale price of the property, typically ranging from 5% to 6% total, which is often split between the listing agent and the buyer’s agent. Commission rates can vary by market and are always discussed and agreed upon before representation begins.

Who typically uses your referral platform?

Our clients include Florida residents, individuals relocating from out of state or abroad, retirees, seasonal residents (snowbirds) and investors seeking trusted local real estate representation.

How is this platform different from other referral options?

Our platform provides clients with direct access to Florida’s most highly recommended local real estate agents. Unlike traditional referral websites with open participation, our agents are hand-selected through a rigorous vetting process to ensure exceptional expertise, professionalism, and consistently outstanding client experiences.

With only one highly recommended agent in each sub-region, what happens if they’re not available to take on new clients?

We closely monitor the number of introductions each agent receives to ensure they can properly serve every client. If an agent’s availability becomes limited, we temporarily pause new introductions and feature another highly recommended local agent until availability returns. Our goal is to make sure every client receives attentive, high-quality service and that there is always a highly recommended agent available to serve our clients.

Verify your phone number to finalize your request

We've sent a 6-digit code via SMS

The code is incorrect. Please try again.

Didn't receive it? Resend code

Your number is secure and will not be shared.

Something went wrong

We couldn't complete your verification right now. Please try again in a few minutes.

Phone Number Verified.
Introduction Sent.

You'll receive an introductory email shortly.
Lance typically follows up within the hour.